According to the different categories that we established previously, we chose the “type of school”. Firstly, when talking about public and private schools, we want to point out that public-private partnerships can be shared into four categories: 1. publicly-funded resources that are publicly managed, 2. privately funded resources that are privately managed, 3. publicly funded resources that are privately managed, and 4. privately funded resources that are publicly managed. The first group basically means the most common form of public school, while the second group means the most common private schools. In Spain, a low percentage of schools are publicly funded and operated, whereas for example in Finland and Germany (where two of our group members come from), most of the schools are like this. (W枚脽mann, Public-Private Partnerships, and Student Achievement: A Cross-Country Analysis, in Peterson & Chakrabarti, 2009). Most of our group members went to a school which was publicly managed and funded. One of our group members went to a school which was privately managed but publicly funded, whereas one went to a school which was privately funded and managed. Due to this, we get to see some differences and similarities between the public and private sector. We are going to take a closer look at the aspects of the different schools, by explaining the differences between a private and a public school.
What comes to the differences between public and private schools, one significant difference is the obligation of wearing a uniform. In public schools, you have the option of wearing the school uniform or your own clothes. However, at the private schools, it’s an obligation to wear it. One of our group members who went to a private school remembers that if you didn’t wear the uniform, you were punished. What comes to Finland, there is no such thing as a school uniform.
Secondly, in the public school, there was an option to choose between religion or an alternative subject, in which the students were taught values and behaviors. The private school, though, and the one which was supported by the state, had religion as a compulsory subject in the elementary school. In the private school funded by public money, you had to pray more or less once a week and you had the First Communion. Again, in Finland, the issue is different. Religion was a mandatory part of the primary, secondary and high school. Only if you were a part of some other religion, you didn’t have to participate, but you would be learning something else instead. This leads us to a conclusion: private schools have autonomy in choosing optative subjects, adapting pedagogical methods and organizing extracurricular activities.
An interesting aspect is that the socio-economic status “[...] has been found to have an association with less positive transitions for children.” (Evangelou 2008, p.2). One member of our group had a friend at secondary school who got more and more problems to continue with the new routines. Not just because of the school system that leaves us just twelve years to finish the school (before it was thirteen years), the greater problem was that the parents didn’t have much money. The student needed help but their parents could not pay for more private tuition. Their solution was that the student went to another school where he/she would finish his/her studies after the 10th class.
Finally, we can say, that the decision of the chosen school will leave its mark on the children. There are a lot of differences between private and public schools and also just between the public schools of each city.
We came to the resolution that we have to take notice of the different aspects of the decision that the children and their parents are making.
Looking in the future and seeing us as teachers, we could have private conversations with each student and their parents at the end of the primary school o to help them with their type of school decision.
Resources:
- Chakrabarti, R., & Peterson, P. E. (2009). School Choice International. (1st ed.) The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts: London, England
- Evangelou, Maria. (2008). What makes a successful transition from primary to secondary school?
- Gayarre, A. L. (2000). Ense帽anza privada-ense帽anza no p煤blica: formas y estatutos en los Estados Miembros de Ia Uni贸n Europea. Revista Espa帽ola de Educaci贸n Comparada, (6), 415-417.